| NAME | SCHOOL | POSITION | YEAR |
|---|---|---|---|
| FIRST TEAM | |||
| Parker Meifert | Greenfield | PItcher | Junior |
| Adam Finn | South Milwaukee | Pitcher | Junior |
| Brayden Schimmel | Whitnall | Pitcher | Junior |
| AJ Clark | Whitnall | Catcher | Soph |
| Evan Alms | Greenfield | Infielder | Senior |
| Rosario Pratchet | Milwaukee Lutheran | Infielder | Senior |
| Josh Diorio | Whitnall | Infielder | Junior |
| Will Lichtenstein | Brown Deer/Shorewood | Infielder | Senior |
| Max Johnson | South Milwaukee | Outfielder | Junior |
| Braylen White | Brown Deer/Shorewood | Outfielder | Soph |
| Dom Greer | Whitnall | Outfielder | Senior |
| Joe Nickolaus | Brown Deer/Shorewood | Utility | Senior |
| Colin Weist | Cudahy | DP | Junior |
| SECOND TEAM | |||
| Jake Rechlitz | Whitnall | Pitcher | Soph |
| Nate Wendricks | Greenfield | Pitcher | Soph |
| Nate Lindner | South Milwaukee | Pitcher | Senior |
| Brett Goggins | Greenfield | Catcher | Junior |
| Dylan Keelan | Whitnall | Infielder | Senior |
| Owen McLellan | Brown Deer/Shorewood | Infielder | Frosh |
| Jayden Valdez | Greenfield | Infielder | Soph |
| Jack Strubel | Whitnall | Infielder | Senior |
| Nate Baak | Whitnall | Outfielder | Senior |
| Ryan Graf | Greenfield | Outfielder | Senior |
| Colin Henry | South Milwaukee | Outfielder | Senior |
| Keegan Reinke | South Milwaukee | Utility | Junior |
| Charlie McQuillen | Brown Deer/Shorewood | DP | Soph |
| HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| Ethan Lindber | Cudahy | Senior | |
| Jackson Meyer | Whitnall | Senior | |
| Jacob Church | Brown Deer/Shorewood | Senior | |
| Lucas Stapleton | South Milwaukee | Frosh | |
| Nolan Litkowiec | Cudahy | Soph | |
| NiJoel Pulliam | Milwaukee Lutheran | Frosh | |
| Mason Klug | Whitnall | Junior | |
| Finn Knoerschild | Brown Deer/Shorewood | Frosh | |
| PLAYER OF THE YEAR | |||
| Brayden Schimmel | Whitnall | Junior | |
| COACH OF THE YEAR | |||
| Jim Fischer | Whitnall |