| NAME | SCHOOL | YEAR |
|---|---|---|
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| Jordan Perez | Greendale | Sr. |
| Reed Timmer | New Berlin Eisenhower | Sr. |
| Eric Lutzen | Pewaukee | Sr. |
| Levi Bradley | Pius XI | Jr. |
| Donovan Jackson | Pius XI | Sr. |
| Steffan Brown | Wauwatosa West | Jr. |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Josh Michaels | Greendale | Jr. |
| David Pulizos | Greendale | So. |
| Scott Reichel | New Berlin West | Sr. |
| Ryan Stopanovich | Pewaukee | Sr. |
| Evan Hansen | Pewaukee | Jr. |
| Andre Carroll | Wauwatosa West | Jr. |
| HONORABLE MENTION | ||
| Brett Uelner | New Berlin Eisenhower | So. |
| Jack Sirek | New Berlin Eisenhower | So. |
| Brendan Bullock | Pius XI | Sr. |
| Blake Harvey | Wauwatosa West | Sr. |
| PLAYER OF THE YEAR | ||
| Reed Timmer | New Berlin Eisenhower | Sr. |