| Player | Pos | Year | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carrington Love (MVP) | G | Senior | Pius XI Popes |
| Kenny Finco | Junior | Arrowhead Warhawks | |
| Larry Fitzgerald | Senior | Pius XI Popes | |
| Jake Ricciardi | Senior | Waukesha North Northstars | |
| Joe Schobert | G | Senior | Waukesha West Wolverines |
| Nathan Tanguay | Junior | Mukwonago Indians |
| Player | Pos | Year | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dominic Cizauskas | G/F | Sophomore | Mukwonago Indians |
| Brandon Kranz | F | Senior | Waukesha West Wolverines |
| Ryan Saeger | F | Senior | Arrowhead Warhawks |
| Eric Solberg | G | Senior | Waukesha West Wolverines |
| Ryan Taugher | G | Senior | Catholic Memorial Crusaders |
| Player | Pos | Year | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nick Blohm | G/F | Junior | Mukwonago Indians |
| Andre Bodden | F/C | Junior | Catholic Memorial Crusaders |
| Mike Dugan | F | Senior | Waukesha West Wolverines |
| Matthew Fox-Whitaker | F | Senior | Pius XI Popes |
| Jake Giffhorn | F | Junior | Catholic Memorial Crusaders |
| Jack Gingrass | G | Senior | Waukesha North Northstars |
| Billy Hirschfeld | C | Sophomore | Arrowhead Warhawks |
| Kevin Koenigs | G | Senior | Waukesha South Blackshirts |
| Paul Miller | G | Sophomore | Kettle Moraine Lasers |
| Aaron Nixon | G | Sophomore | Mukwonago Indians |
| Jamale Robinson | C | Senior | Pius XI Popes |
| Ty Sabin | G | Junior | Catholic Memorial Crusaders |
| Ryan Smith | G | Sophomore | Waukesha South Blackshirts |
| Joe Wegner | F | Senior | Waukesha North Northstars |