| Player | Pos | Year | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chad Mathwig (MVP) | F | Senior | New Berlin West Vikings |
| Jordan Edgerson | F | Junior | Pewaukee Pirates |
| Kierre Ogbonna | P | Senior | Brown Deer Falcons |
| Dan Sidesky | G/F | Junior | New Berlin West Vikings |
| Trevor Wattawa | Junior | Saint Thomas More Cavaliers |
| Player | Pos | Year | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brad Duggan | F | Senior | New Berlin West Vikings |
| Deion Jackson-Body | G | Junior | Shorewood Greyhounds |
| Teontae Morgan | G/F | Junior | Cudahy Packers |
| David Reese | G | Senior | Pewaukee Pirates |
| Justin Shervey | F | Junior | Saint Thomas More Cavaliers |
| Player | Pos | Year | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Greg Boknevitz | G | Junior | Saint Francis Mariners |
| Donovan Freeman | G | Sophomore | Shorewood Greyhounds |
| Mark Kaczynski | G | Senior | New Berlin West Vikings |
| Joziah Mallett | G | Senior | Brown Deer Falcons |
| Trayvon Palmer | G/P | Sophomore | Brown Deer Falcons |
| Nick Reid | G | Junior | Saint Thomas More Cavaliers |
| Ben Steker | F | Junior | Pewaukee Pirates |
| Daniel Torres | F | Senior | Saint Thomas More Cavaliers |