| Player | Pos | Year | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Josh Baker (MVP) | F | Senior | University School Wildcats |
| Matt Brown (MVP) | D | Senior | Saint John's NW Military Academy Lancers |
| Daniel Axtman | MF | Sophomore | Living Word Lutheran Timberwolves |
| Angel Bahena | F | Freshmen | Dominican Knights |
| Ricky Kustner | F | Senior | Brookfield Academy Blue Knights |
| Ian McKinney | D | Senior | University School Wildcats |
| Isaac Schlenker | MF | Sophomore | University School Wildcats |
| Robby Schmidt | MF | Junior | University School Wildcats |
| Connor Schwartz | MF | Junior | Dominican Knights |
| Ryan Send | D | Sophomore | Brookfield Academy Blue Knights |
| Jason Seter | D | Sophomore | University School Wildcats |
| Jack Wells | GK | Sophomore | University School Wildcats |
| Player | Pos | Year | Team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Leo Castro-Lopez | MF | Senior | Brookfield Academy Blue Knights |
| Peter Cronin | D | Senior | Dominican Knights |
| Daniel Curiel Aduchi | MF | Senior | Saint John's NW Military Academy Lancers |
| Herbert Forbes | D | Junior | Messmer Bishops |
| Rolando Garcia | MF | Senior | Messmer Bishops |
| David Gramling | MF | Sophomore | Brookfield Academy Blue Knights |
| Michael Hur | D | Junior | Brookfield Academy Blue Knights |
| Bouw John | D | Junior | Wayland Academy Big Red |
| Lanre Olanyian | GK | Senior | Brookfield Academy Blue Knights |
| Enrique Pariente | F | Junior | Saint John's NW Military Academy Lancers |
| Giovanni Roman | F | Sophomore | Messmer Bishops |
| Joshua Senkbeil | F | Freshmen | Living Word Lutheran Timberwolves |