| NAME | SCHOOL | POSITION | YEAR |
|---|---|---|---|
| FIRST TEAM | |||
| Andrew Setter | Kenosha St. Joseph | P | Junior |
| Sawyer Smith | Shoreland Lutheran | P | Senior |
| Frank McGuire | Kenosha St. Joseph | C | Senior |
| Jacob Ashmus | Kenosha St. Joseph | INF | Junior |
| Brady Davidson | Kenosha St. Joseph | INF | Soph |
| Jacob Hartlaub | Martin Luther | INF | Senior |
| Alex Alicea | St. Thomas More | INF | Soph |
| Jack Davidson | Kenosha St. Joseph | OF | Senior |
| Aaron Roslowski | Shoreland Lutheran | OF | Senior |
| Bailey Lemke | Martin Luther | OF | Senior |
| Conner Robertson | Dominican | Utility | Junior |
| SECOND TEAM | |||
| Luke Schuler | Kenosha St. Joseph | P | Soph |
| Isaiah Malison | St. Thomas More | P | Junior |
| Brady Johnson | St. Thomas More | C | Frosh |
| Maximillian McCarville | Kenosha St. Joseph | INF | Senior |
| Kyle Alivo | St. Thomas More | INF | Frosh |
| Kody Krekling | Racine Luth/Prairie | INF | Senior |
| Logan Marino | Racine St. Cats | INF | Senior |
| Matt Schulte | Kenosha St. Joseph | OF | Junior |
| Jacob Brooks | St. Thomas More | OF | Soph |
| Ben Tietyen | Racine Luth/Prairie | OF | Junior |
| Alex Vogt | Catholic Central | Utility | Frosh |
| HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| Peter Ruffolo | Kenosha St. Joseph | Senior | |
| Oliver Gonzalez | St. Thomas More | Frosh | |
| Elijah Niemiec | St. Thomas More | Soph | |
| Konnor Hill | Shoreland Lutheran | Senior | |
| David Ripke | Shoreland Lutheran | Soph | |
| Nick Schemming | Shoreland Lutheran | Senior | |
| Jayce Jaramillo | Racine Luth/Prairie | Soph | |
| Jason Schmierer | Racine Luth/Prairie | Soph | |
| Seth Hultman | Racine Luth/Prairie | Junior | |
| Gavin Consigny | Martin Luther | Junior | |
| Ian Stefaniak | Dominican | Junior | |
| Charlie Wahlen | Dominican | Frosh | |
| Cal Miles | Catholic Central | Junior | |
| Danny von Rabenau | Catholic Central | Soph | |
| Bennett Spolar | Racine St. Cats | Senior | |
| PLAYER OF THE YEAR | Sawyer Smith | Shoreland Lutheran |