| NAME | SCHOOL | POSITION | YEAR |
|---|---|---|---|
| FIRST TEAM | |||
| James Reese | University School | P | Junior |
| Tim Frerking | Lake Country Lutheran | P | Junior |
| Michael Hoefgen | Brookfield Academy | P | Junior |
| Vidal Colon | University School | INF | Soph |
| Gavin Theis | Lake Country Lutheran | INF | Senior |
| Ben Lubbers | Lake Country Lutheran | INF | Junior |
| Dillon Rosado | Brookfield Academy | INF | Junior |
| Jonathan Kim | Brookfield Academy | OF | Junior |
| John Nehls | Lake Country Lutheran | OF | Junior |
| Jimmy Fox | University School | OF | Senior |
| Sam Heicher | Lake Country Lutheran | C | Senior |
| Gunnar Grosenick | Lake Country Lutheran | Utility | Junior |
| SECOND TEAM | |||
| Nolan Kahle | Brookfield Academy | P | Junior |
| Aiden Yauchler | SJNMA | P | Senior |
| Lucas Hartmann | Kenosha Christian Life | P | Frosh |
| Aiden Anderson | Kenosha Christian Life | P | Junior |
| Graham Kasten | University School | INF | Frosh |
| Matt Hanke | SJNMA | INF | Senior |
| Perry Foster II | Kenosha Christian Life | INF | Senior |
| Ryan Campbell | Brookfield Academy | INF | Junior |
| Aaron Sellhausen | Saint Francis | OF | Junior |
| Branden White | University School | OF | Senior |
| Brett Powers | Lake Country Lutheran | OF | Junior |
| Donald Austin | SJNMA | C | Senior |
| Carter Ellenson | Saint Francis | Utility | Junior |
| HONORABLE MENTION | |||
| Brady Gomilla | Brookfield Academy | Frosh | |
| Cooper Beck | Kenosha Christian Life | Frosh | |
| Noah Howard | Lake Country Lutheran | Junior | |
| Josh Pavlik | Lake Country Lutheran | Junior | |
| Nathan Culli | Living Word Lutheran | Junior | |
| Reese Stanley | Saint Francis | Senior | |
| Jaiden Wilson | Saint Francis | Junior | |
| Dominic Reisner | SJNMA | Junior | |
| Mike Schoon | University School | Frosh | |
| Henry Vincent | University School | ||
| Reid Woods | University School | Senior | |
| PLAYER OF THE YEAR | Gavin Theis | Lake Country Lutheran | |
| COACH OF THE YEAR | Greg Peters | Heritage Christian |