| NAME | SCHOOL | YEAR |
|---|---|---|
| FIRST TEAM | ||
| Aiden Brosinski | De Soto | Senior |
| Andrew Thompson | De Soto | Junior |
| Josh Boardman | De Soto | Senior |
| Alex Schoville | De Soto | Senior |
| Benji Clary | Ithaca | Junior |
| Chase Keller | Ithaca | Junior |
| Jed Scallon | Ithaca | Junior |
| Caleb Marchwick | Ithaca | Junior |
| Ashton Swanson | Seneca | Junior |
| Jaden Berger | Wauzeka-Steuben | Senior |
| Jonah Reichmann | Wauzeka-Steuben | Junior |
| Cayden Lomas | Wauzeka-Steuben | Soph |
| SECOND TEAM | ||
| Jacob Manning | Ithaca | Junior |
| Hunter Fowell | Kickapoo/La Farge | Senior |
| Garrett Peterson | Kickapoo/La Farge | Senior |
| Kaden Wallin | Seneca | Junior |
| Evan Payne | Seneca | Soph |
| Anthony Hall | Seneca | Junior |
| Mitchell Colson | Wauzeka-Steuben | Junior |
| Garret Kapinus | Wauzeka-Steuben | Junior |
| David Bauer | Weston | Senior |
| Hunter Schmitt | Weston | Senior |
| Hayden VanCoulter | Weston | Senior |
| HONORABLE MENTION | ||
| Jacob Kurszewski | De Soto | Senior |
| Nolan Alexander | Kickapoo/La Farge | Soph |
| Brock Nelson | Ithaca | Junior |
| Delvin Smith | North Crawford | Senior |
| Joey Oppriecht | Seneca | Senior |
| Isaac Reichmann | Wauzeka-Steuben | Junior |
| CO-PITCHERS OF THE YEAR | Ashton Swanson | Seneca |
| Benji Clary | Ithaca | |
| Alex Schoville | De Soto | |
| PLAYER OF THE YEAR | Ashton Swanson | Seneca |
| COACH OF THE YEAR | Danny Clary | Ithaca |